From the Conflict to Conspiracy: Chengguan and Vendors Contact Logic: A Case Study in Hanzhengjie Governance
-
摘要: 探讨了社会治理议题中城管与街头摊贩关系从冲突到合谋的外在表现和内在形成机制。以汉正街城管执法人员为研究对象,通过参与观察和案例分析,以动态视角考察城管队员的一线执法行为,指出城管队员作为政府执法者在进行社会治理过程中,因其执法权利受到来自各方制约以至于其为顺利完成任务而与摊贩合谋,成为当前城市管理中的常见现象。最后,摊贩的存在是当前社会发展的必然产物,政府应承认摊贩存在的必要性,变“清理”为“管理”,从而提高社会治理水平,减少社会冲突。Abstract: This paper focuses on the relationship between the chengguan and street vendors in social governance issues from conflict to conspire external manifestations and formation mechanism. Taking Hanzhengjie law enforcement officers as an example, through the participant observation and case analysis, from the frontline law enforcement perspective of the dynamic behavior of the inspectors, the paper pointed out that as a government law enforcement inspectors carrying out the process of the social governance, its enforcement rights are restricted from all sides, so in order to get the successful completion of the tasks they have conspired, which has become a common phenomenon in the current city administration. Finally, the existence of hawkersis the inevitable product of the current social development, the Government should be responsive to community needs and give the recognition of the necessity, change“clean”to “management” so as to improve the social governance and reduce social conflicts.
-
Key words:
- chengguan law enforcement /
- vendors /
- conflict /
- conspiracy /
- communication logic /
- social governance cities
-
[1] 景天魁.源头治理——社会治理有效性的基础和前提[J]. 北京工业大学学报(社会科学版),2014(3):1-6. [2] 何兵.城管追逐与摊贩抵抗: 摊贩管理中的利益冲突与法律调整[J]. 中国法学,2008(5):159-169. [3] 陈那波,卢施羽.场域转换中的默契互动——中国“城管”的自由裁量行为及其逻辑[J]. 管理世界,2013(10):62-80. [4] 汪演元.社会中的法理[M].北京:中国法律出版社,2012:294-351. [5] 张晒.权力生产与社会控制: “城管与摊贩”故事背后的逻辑[J]. 社会学评论,2014(4):89-96. [6] ELLISK.‘Street-level bureaucracy’revisited: the changing face of frontline discretion in adult social care in england[J]. Social Policy & Administration,2011(3):221-244. [7] 周亚鹰.我是城管[M].北京:大众文艺出版社,2012:34. [8] 刘阳.北京城管研究[D].北京: 北京大学,2011:27. [9] 玛丽·道格拉斯.制度如何思考[M].张晨曲,译, 北京: 经济管理出版社,2013:80. [10] 杨小军.城管执法机构性质与城管执法体制[J]. 行政管理改革,2010(4):24-27. [11] 杨解军.秩序、权力与法律控制: 行政处罚法研究(增补本)[M].成都:四川大学出版社,1999:374. [12] 关保英.行政综合执法研究[C]. 2002年政府法制研究论文论, 上海: 上海市行政法研究所,2002. [13] JOWELLJ.The legal control of administrative discretion[M].Oxford:Oxford University Press.1973:18 [14] 丛雅静.城镇居民收入差距与消费需求的关系研究——基于ECM模型[J]. 调研世界,2014(6):12-17. [15] 李瑾. 国内外摊贩经济管理研究综述(上)[EB/OL]. (2007-03-16)[2016-01-10]. http://lhsr.sh.gov.cn/sites/lhsr/neirong.aspx?ctgid=3a222e8f-e1e5-4737-8697-41de8c789e31&infid=e294cfb6-715d-4e60-bb21-01e0aa5579ed. [16] 马克思. 资本论:1卷[M].北京:人民出版社,1958:839. [17] 韩婷婷,王超.30万无照游商大战城管,京城“游击战”没完没了[J].中国青年报,2006-08-15(06). [18] 城管综合执法状况研究课题组. 西安市临潼区城管综合执法状况观察报告[J]. 法学,2009(6):78-93 [19] WILLIAMS CC,WINDEBANKJ.Black market work in the european community: peripheral work for peripheral areas[J].International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,1995(19):23-39. [20] 宋志刚.城管来了[M].北京:北京理工大学出版社,2011:63-70. [21] 叶娟丽,马骏.公共行政中的街头官僚理论[J]. 武汉大学学报(社会科学版),2003(5):612-618. [22] 陈那波,卢施羽.场域转换中的默契互动——中国“城管”的自由裁量行为及其逻辑[J]. 管理世界,2013(10):62-80. [23] Illy HF.Regulation and evasion: street vendors in manila[J].Policy Sciences,1986(1):61-81. [24] 钱穆.中国历代政治得失[M].上海: 生活、读书、新知三联书店,2004:47. [25] 陆学艺.加快社会建设: 我国当前和今后的重大战略任务[J]. 北京工业大学学报(社会科学版),2013(2):1-6.
点击查看大图
计量
- 文章访问数: 38
- HTML全文浏览量: 31
- PDF下载量: 0
- 被引次数: 0