熵权法对三种添加剂改良高含量马铃薯全粉挂面工艺研究

李安林; 黎璐; 粟立丹; 熊双丽

doi:10.13386/j.issn1002-0306.2022080169

熵权法对三种添加剂改良高含量马铃薯全粉挂面工艺研究

doi: 10.13386/j.issn1002-0306.2022080169

李安林^1,,
黎璐²,
粟立丹²,
熊双丽^2,*, ,

1.
四川旅游学院图书馆，四川成都 621010
2.
四川旅游学院食品学院，四川成都 610100

基金项目: 四川旅游学院科研团队项目（21SCTUTY03）。

详细信息

作者简介:
李安林（1977−），男，硕士研究生，研究方向：功能性食品加工与安全，E-mail：313266270@qq.com

通讯作者:
熊双丽（1977−），女，博士，教授，研究方向：功能性食品加工与安全，E-mail：lxberry225@163.com

中图分类号: TS215
计量
- 文章访问数: 16
- HTML全文浏览量: 21
- PDF下载量: 0
- 被引次数: 0
出版历程
- 收稿日期: 2022-08-18
- 刊出日期: 2023-05-15

Improving Technology for High Content Potato Noodle with Three Additives Based on Entropy Weight Method

LI Anlin^1
,,
LI Lu²,
SU Lidan²,
XIONG Shuangli^{2,*
, ,}

1.
Library, Sichuan Tourism University, Chengdu 610100, China
2.
Food College, Sichuan Tourism University, Chengdu 610100, China

摘要

摘要: 为优化马铃薯全粉挂面改良工艺，论文首先以高筋小麦粉、马铃薯全粉为主要原料，利用单因素结合正交试验设计和熵权法，探究大豆分离蛋白、瓜尔豆胶、谷氨酰胺转氨酶对马铃薯全粉挂面感官品质和蒸煮特性的影响，再利用熵权法分析挂面最佳干燥温度。结果表明，3种改良剂（大豆分离蛋白、瓜尔豆胶、谷氨酰胺转氨酶）均对38%马铃薯全粉挂面的蒸煮特性和感官品质有较好的改善作用。对挂面感官品质和综合得分的影响程度由大到小依次为大豆分离蛋白、瓜尔豆胶、谷氨酰胺转氨酶，最优配方为大豆分离蛋白6%、瓜尔豆胶0.9%、谷氨酰胺转氨酶1.5%。挂面综合得分0.2028，感官评分达84.83分。熵权法综合评价干燥过程中挂面感官评分、蒸煮损失率、吸水率、硬度、弹性和咀嚼性，发现干燥温度70℃时挂面品质最佳，感官评分 84.67±0.40，蒸煮损失率8.79%±0.03%，吸水率140.33%±1.52%，硬度（4.29±0.11）N，熟断条率为0%。单因素、正交设计试验结合熵权法能很好综合评价马铃薯挂面品质，该工艺条件下挂面综合品质高。
- 马铃薯 /
- 挂面 /
- 大豆分离蛋白 /
- 瓜尔豆胶 /
- 谷氨酰胺转氨酶 /
- 工艺
Abstract: The aim of the article was to optimize the processing technology of potato flour noodles. High gluten wheat flour and potato powder were used as the main raw materials. The single factor experiment, orthogonal design experiment and entropy weight methods were adopted to explore the effect of soybean protein isolate, transglutaminase and guar gum on potato noodle. The results showed that the cooking characteristics and sensory quality of 38% potato noodle were improved by the three modifiers. The order of the factors affecting the sensory quality of potato noodle from big to small was soybean protein isolate, guar gum, glutamine transaminase, respectively. The best formulation was obtained by combining range analysis and entropy weight method, which was 6% soy protein isolate, 0.9% guar gum and 1.5% transglutaminase. According to the above formula, the potato noodle had a comprehensive score of 0.2028, a sensory score of 84.83. The entropy weight method comprehensively was used to evaluate the general quality of dried noodles including sensory score, cooking loss rate, water absorption rate, hardness, elasticity and chewiness quality. It was found that the optimum drying temperature was 70 ℃, the sensory score was 84.67±0.40, cooking loss rate was 8.79%±0.03%, water absorption was 140.33%±1.52%, hardness was (4.29±0.11) N and the cooked breaking rate was 0%. Single factor, orthogonal design experiment combined with entropy weight method could comprehensively evaluate the quality of potato noodle, and the comprehensive quality of potato noodle was higher under this technological condition.
- potato /
- dried noodle /
- soybean protein isolate /
- guar gum /
- transglutaminase /
- technology

HTML全文

图 1 挂面加工工艺流程图

Figure 1. Schematic diagram of dry noodle processing process

下载: 全尺寸图片幻灯片

表 1 正交试验因素水平设计

Table 1. Factors and levels for orthogonal design experiment

水平	因素
水平	大豆分离蛋白添加量（A，%）	瓜尔胶添加量（B，%）	谷氨酰胺转氨酶添加量（C，%）
1	4.0	0.9	1.0
2	6.0	1.2	1.5
3	8.0	1.5	2.0

下载: 导出CSV

表 2 感官评定评分标准

Table 2. Standard of sensory evaluation

项目	分值（分）	评分标准
色泽	10	挂面呈奶黄色，光亮为7.5～10分；亮度一般为5～7.4分；颜色发暗发灰，亮度差为1～4.9分
表观状态	10	挂面表面结构细密、光滑透亮为7.5～10分；处于中间态为5.0～7.4分；表面粗糙、膨胀、变形严重为1～4.9分
软硬度	20	用牙齿咬断一根挂面需要的力道，力道适中为16～20分；稍偏硬或偏软为11～15分；太硬或太软为1～10分
韧性	25	咀嚼挂面时，富有弹性有咬劲为20～25分；一般为14～19分；弹性不足，咬劲差或很硬为1～13分
粘性	25	咀嚼时不粘牙、爽口为20～25分；较爽口、稍粘牙为14～19分；发粘、不爽口为10～13分
光滑性	5	口感光滑为4.2～5分；光滑程度一般为2～4.1分；光滑程度差为1～1.9分
食味	5	品尝时具有小麦的清香味和马铃薯的香味4.2～5分；基本无异味为2～4.1分；有异味为1～1.9分

下载: 导出CSV

表 3 大豆分离蛋白对马铃薯挂面感官评分和蒸煮特性的影响

Table 3. Effects of soybean protein isolate on sensory score and cooking characteristics of potato noodles

大豆分离蛋白含量（%）	感官评分（分）	蒸煮损失率（%）	熟断条率（%）	最佳蒸煮时间（min）	吸水率（%）
0	62.30±1.45^d	33.38±0.98^a	47.50±2.50^a	3.17±0.06^c	145.00±1.73^d
2	74.93±1.66^c	18.46±0.41^c	14.17±1.44^b	5.50±0.10^b	155.67±1.24^b
4	76.50±1.47^c	15.55±0.44^d	0.83±1.44^d	5.14±0.11^b	163.67±2.51^a
6	81.93±0.91^a	15.25±0.21^d	0.00±0.00^d	5.35±0.09^b	154.67±2.09^b
8	79.13±0.68^b	16.20±1.51^d	1.67±1.44^d	5.57±0.09^b	153.66±1.15^bc
10	74.77±0.67^c	20.07±1.66^b	11.67±1.44^c	6.36±0.11^a	151.33±1.52^c
注：同列数字肩注相同字母表示不显著（P>0.05）；同列数字肩注不相同字母表示差异显著（P<0.05）；表2~表3同。

下载: 导出CSV

表 4 瓜尔豆胶对马铃薯挂面感官评分和蒸煮特性的影响

Table 4. Effects of guar gum on sensory score and cooking characteristics of potato noodles

瓜尔豆胶含量（%）	感官评分（分）	蒸煮损失率（%）	熟断条率（%）	最佳蒸煮时间（min）	吸水率（%）
0	62.30±1.45^d	33.38±0.98^a	47.50±2.50^a	3.14±0.11^d	145.01±1.00^a
0.3	69.93±1.23^c	14.82±0.51^b	4.17±1.44^b	4.67±0.14^c	143.04±2.01^ab
0.6	70.50±0.98^c	14.18±0.82^b	0.00±0.00^d	5.43±0.12^b	142.00±1.00^b
0.9	80.70±1.22^a	9.76±1.03^d	2.50±2.50^bc	5.42±0.11^b	139.67±0.58^c
1.2	78.80±1.23^ab	9.44±1.48^d	0.83±1.44^cd	6.60±0.10^a	137.67±1.53^c
1.5	78.13±2.06^b	12.23±1.28^c	0.00±0.00^d	5.55±0.18^b	133.67±1.52^d

下载: 导出CSV

表 5 谷氨酰胺转氨酶对马铃薯挂面感官评分和蒸煮特性的影响

Table 5. Effects of glutamine aminotransferase on sensory score and cooking characteristics of potato noodles

谷氨酰胺转氨酶含量（%）	感官评分（分）	蒸煮损失率（%）	熟断条率（%）	最佳蒸煮时间（min）	吸水率（%）
0.0	62.30±1.45^e	33.38±0.98^a	47.50±2.51^a	3.23±0.13^d	145.00±2.64^d
0.5	68.07±0.42^d	9.90±1.01^d	18.50±3.77^b	3.50±0.00^c	154.67±1.52^c
1.0	73.13±0.91^c	11.63±0.58^c	6.67±2.89^c	4.12±0.03^b	163.33±2.08^b
1.5	77.16±1.32^b	9.85±0.16^d	1.67±1.44^d	4.33±0.14^a	170.67±2.51^a
2.0	79.47±0.61^a	13.44±0.76^b	0.83±1.44^d	4.21±0.10^ab	166.00±2.64^b
2.5	72.93±1.66^c	14.29±1.20^b	7.50±5.00^c	4.20±0.05^ab	155.67±2.52^c

下载: 导出CSV

表 6 正交试验设计及结果

Table 6. Design and results of orthogonal experiment

实验号	A	B	C	蒸煮损失率（%）	感官评分（分）	综合得分
1	1	1	1	10.13	78.23	0.0693
2	1	2	2	9.08	79.73	0.1192
3	1	3	3	8.40	76.90	0.0867
4	2	1	2	9.23	84.83	0.2028
5	2	2	3	9.45	80.30	0.1204
6	2	3	1	8.18	83.14	0.1983
7	3	1	3	9.30	79.30	0.1068
8	3	2	1	9.90	78.21	0.0743
9	3	3	2	10.88	76.52	0.0227
蒸煮损失率
K₁	27.61	28.66	28.21
K₂	26.86	28.43	29.19
K₃	30.08	27.46	27.15
k₁	9.20	9.55	9.40
k₂	8.95	9.48	9.73
k₃	10.03	9.15	9.05
R	1.08	0.40	0.68
优水平	A₂	B₃	C₃
感官评分
K₁	234.80	242.34	239.50
K₂	248.21	238.20	241.12
K₃	234.11	236.55	236.56
k₁	78.27	80.77	79.83
k₂	82.73	79.40	80.33
k₃	78.76	78.83	78.33
R	4.73	1.93	1.53
优水平	A₂	B₁	C₂
综合得分
K₁	0.2761	0.3856	0.3341
K₂	0.5182	0.3173	0.3561
K₃	0.2057	0.2971	0.3148
k₁	0.0920	0.1285	0.1113
k₂	0.1727	0.1058	0.1187
k₃	0.0686	0.0873	0.1049
R	0.1041	0.0412	0.0138
优水平	A₂	B₁	C₂

下载: 导出CSV

表 7 干燥温度对马铃薯挂面感官评分、蒸煮和质构特性的影响

Table 7. Effects of drying temperature on sensory score, cooking characteristics and texture of potato noodles

温度（℃）	感官评分（分）	蒸煮损失率（%）	最佳蒸煮时间（min）	吸水率（%）	硬度（N）	弹性（mm）	咀嚼性（mJ）	综合得分
40	82.70±0.46^c	9.09±0.04^a	4.17±0.14^e	142.67±1.53^c	3.61±0.41^bc	1.80±0.06^bc	1.23±0.05^bc	0.1062
50	83.47±0.50^b	9.10±0.03^a	4.83±0.14^d	144.01±1.00^c	3.09±0.21^d	1.92±0.05^ab	2.27±0.07^c	0.1604
60	84.85±0.21^a	8.86±0.03^c	5.25±0.09^c	143.05±1.00^c	3.87±0.31^ab	1.94±0.02^ab	1.48±0.06^b	0.2248
70	84.67±0.40^a	8.79±0.03^d	5.58±0.14^b	140.33±1.52^d	4.29±0.11^a	2.00±0.04^a	1.27±0.12^d	0.2393
80	83.67±0.15^b	8.89±0.04^c	5.75±0.11^b	147.00±1.01^b	3.21±0.10^c	1.72±0.08^c	1.19±0.13^c	0.1464
90	83.60±0.26^b	8.98±0.04^b	6.00±0.11^a	150.67±1.11^a	3.39±0.23^c	1.64±0.03^c	0.95±0.04^a	0.1317

下载: 导出CSV

参考文献(29)

[1]	唐峥. 农科院马铃薯团队: 我国马铃薯种植面积和总产量居世界首位[EB/OL].[2022-08-10]. https://baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1739929452976657014&wfr=spider&for=pc. TANG Z. CAAS po-tato team: China's potato planting area and total production tops the world[EB/OL].[2022-08-10]. https://baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1739929452976657014&wfr=spider&for=pc.
[2]	ZAHEER K, AKHTAR M H. Potato production, usage, and nutrition—A review[J]. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition,2016,56:711−721. doi: 10.1080/10408398.2012.724479
[3]	ZHOU L, MU T H, MA M M, et al. Nutritional evaluation of different cultivars of potatoes (Solanum tuberosum L.) from China by grey relational analysis (GRA) and its application in potato steamed bread making [J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture 2019, 18(1): 231-24.
[4]	LIANG D, ZHANG L, CHEN H Z, et al. Potato resistant starch inhibits diet-induced obesity by modifying the composition of intestinal microbiota and their metabolites in obese mice[J]. International Journal of Biological Macromolecules,2021,180:458−469. doi: 10.1016/j.ijbiomac.2021.02.209
[5]	GOURINENI V, STEWART M L, WILCOX M L, et al. Nutritional bar with potato-based resistant starch attenuated post-prandial glucose and insulin response in healthy adults[J]. Foods,2020,9(11):1−11.
[6]	罗其友, 伦闰琪, 高明杰, 等. 2021-2025 年我国马铃薯产业高质量发展战略路径[J]. 中国农业资源与区划,2022,43(3):37−45. [LUO Q Y, LUN R Q, GAO M J, et al. Strategy path of high-quality development of potato industry in China during from 2021 to 2025[J]. Journal of China Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning,2022,43(3):37−45.
[7]	熊拯, 郭兴凤, 石晶. 大豆分离蛋白的提取及其在面制品中的应用[J]. 粮油食品科技,2006(6):59−61. [XIONG Z, GUO X F, SHI J. The extraction of soybean protein isolated and its applications in flour products[J]. Science and Technology of Cereals, Oils and Foods,2006(6):59−61.
[8]	魏林. 瓜尔豆胶对面条品质特性的影响[J]. 粮食与油脂,2021,34(9):60−62,72. [WEI L. The extraction of soybean protein isolated and its applications in flour products[J]. Cereals & Oils,2021,34(9):60−62,72. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1008-9578.2021.09.015
[9]	周中凯, 邢同浩, 孔宇. 谷氨酰胺转氨酶在面筋和非面筋质制品中应用[J]. 粮食与油脂,2013,26(2):9−11. [ZHOU Z K, XING T H, KONG Y. Applications of transglutaminase in gluen and non-gluten products[J]. Cereals & Oils,2013,26(2):9−11.
[10]	张云亮, 窦博鑫, 刘丽宅, 等. 基于变异系数法分析四种改良剂对马铃薯面条品质的影响[J]. 食品工业科技,2021,42(5):26−32. [ZHANG Y L, DOU B X, LIU L Z, et al. Analysis of effects of four improvers on quality of potato noodles based on the coefficient of variation method[J]. Science and Technology of Food Industry,2021,42(5):26−32.
[11]	公艳, 熊双丽, 彭凌, 等. 响应面-主成分分析法优化马铃薯挂面工艺[J]. 食品工业科技,2017(23):143−150. [GONG Y, XIONG S L, PENG L, et al. Optimization of potato noodles technology by response surface methodology and principal component analysis[J]. Science and Technology of Food Industry,2017(23):143−150.
[12]	杨健, 康建平, 张星灿, 等. 高含量马铃薯全粉挂面品质改良剂的研究[J]. 粮油食品科技,2019,27(5):14−20. [YANG J, KANG J P, ZHANG X C, et al. Study on quality improver of high content potato dried noodles[J]. Science and Technology of Cereals, Oils and Foods,2019,27(5):14−20.
[13]	OJUKWU M, OFOEDU C, SEOW E K, et al. Optimization of soy protein isolate, microbial transglutaminase and glucono-δ-lactone in gluten-free rice noodles[J]. Journal of the science of food and agriculture,2021,101(9):3732−3741. doi: 10.1002/jsfa.11004
[14]	国家粮食局. LS/T 3212-2014 挂面[S]. 北京: 中国标准出版社, 2014 State Administration of Grain. LS/T 3212-2014 Dried noodle[S]. Beijing: Standards Press of China, 2014.
[15]	KANG M J, CHUNG S J, KIM S S. The effects of transglutaminase and refrigerated storage on the physicochemical properties of whole wheat dough and noodles[J]. Foods,2021,10:1−18.
[16]	中华人民共和国国家卫生和计划生育委员会. GB 5009.3-2016 食品安全国家标准食品中水分的测定[S]. 北京: 中国标准出版社, 2016. National Health and Family Planning Commission of the People's Republic of China. GB 5009.3-2016 National Food Safety Standard. Determination of moisture in food[S]. Beijing: Standards Press of China, 2016.
[17]	张旭. 马铃薯全粉面条研制[D]. 雅安: 四川农业大学, 2019 ZHANG X. Development of potato granule noodles[D]. Yaan: Sichuan Agricultural University, 2019.
[18]	段禄峰, 唐文文. 基于熵权法的西部地区农村电子商务发展水平分析[J]. 江苏农业科学,2017,45(9):292−295. [DUAN L F, TANG W W. Analysis of the development level of rural e-commerce in western region based on entropy method[J]. Jiangsu Agricultural Sciences,2017,45(9):292−295.
[19]	孙步忠, 范恒, 黄士娟, 等. 基于趋优融合灰色熵权法的生态经济综合指数动态评价——以江西省为例[J]. 生态经济,2017,33(12):77−82. [FAN B Z, FAN H, HUANG S J, et al. Dynamic evaluation of comprehensive eco-economic index based on convergent fusion grey entropy weight method-Jiangxi Province as an example[J]. Ecological Economy,2017,33(12):77−82.
[20]	BAINY E M, CORREDIG M, POYSA V, et al. Assessment of the effects of soy protein isolates with different protein compositions on gluten thermosetting gelation[J]. Food Research International,2010,43(6):1684−1691. doi: 10.1016/j.foodres.2010.05.010
[21]	LI X Y, HU H H, XU F, et al. Effects of aleuronerich fraction on the hydration and rheological properties attributes of wheat dough[J]. International Journal of Food Science and Technology,2019,54(5):1777−1786. doi: 10.1111/ijfs.14073
[22]	陈前, 李娜, 贺晓光, 等. 瓜尔豆胶对马铃薯-小麦混合粉面团质构和流变特性的影响[J]. 食品工业科技,2020,41(6):198−203. [CHEN Q, LI N, HE X G, et al. Effect of guar gum on texture and rheology property of potato-wheat dough[J]. Science and Technology of Food Industry,2020,41(6):198−203.
[23]	吴娜娜, 杨庭, 谭斌, 等. 谷氨酰胺转氨酶对挤压糙米粉面团蛋白特性和面条品质的影响[J]. 中国粮油学报,2017,32(7):28−32. [WU N N, YANG T, TAN B, et al. Effect of TG on the protein properties of dough and quality of noodles prepared from extruded brown rice flour[J]. Journal of the Chinese Cereals and Oils Association,2017,32(7):28−32. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1003-0174.2017.07.005
[24]	王琼, 卢聪, 李法云, 等. 基于主成分分析和熵权法的河流生境质量评价方法—以清河为例[J]. 生态学报,2017,36(4):185−193. [WANG Q, LU C, LI F Y, et al. A method for evaluating river habitat quality based on principal component analysis and entropy weighting method: The case of Qinghe River[J]. Ecological Economy,2017,36(4):185−193.
[25]	何瑾璇, 刘翀. 干燥过程淀粉与蛋白质变化对挂面品质影响的研究进展[J]. 粮食与油脂,2021,34(6):10−13. [HE J X, LIU C. Research progress on the effects of starch and protein changes on the quality of dried noodles during the drying process[J]. Cereals & Oils,2021,34(6):10−13.
[26]	WANG Z, MA S, SUN B H, et al. Effects of thermal properties and behavior of wheat starch and gluten on their interaction: A review[J]. International Journal of Biological Macromolecules,2021,177:474−484. doi: 10.1016/j.ijbiomac.2021.02.175
[27]	刘婧, 熊汉国. 正交优化马铃薯鱼面生产工艺研究[J]. 中国调味品,2018,43(7):95−98. [LIU J, XIONG H G. Study on the production technology of potato fish noodles with orthogonal optimization[J]. China Condiment,2018,43(7):95−98.
[28]	郭颖. 不同烘干温度对挂面品质影响的研究[D]. 郑州: 河南工业大学, 2015 GUO Y. The study of the effects of different drying temperatures[D]. Zhengzhou: Henan University of Technology, 2015.
[29]	李叶贝, 任广跃, 屈展平, 等. 基于变异系数法对不同干燥方法马铃薯全粉复合面条品质的评价[J]. 食品科学,2020,41(1):48−54. [LI Y B, REN G Y, QU Z P, et al. Evaluating the quality of noodles incorporated with potato flour dried by different drying methods based on coefficient of variation[J]. Food Chemistry,2020,41(1):48−54.